News archive 2010

Report into pay bargaining arrangements

01 Feb 2010, PR 23/10

A new report by Professor Alison Wolf, Department of Management, published today by liberal think tank CentreForum, calls for sweeping reforms in pay bargaining arrangements.

In ‘More than we bargained for: the social and economic costs of national wage bargaining.’ Professor Wolf attacks national pay systems that ignore local differences, handicap struggling regional economies, and make it impossible for public sector managers and institutions to cope sensibly with our fiscal crisis.

As Professor Wolf explains, ‘The current national pay system may seem equitable at first blush. In fact, it is nothing of the sort. It does real damage to local services and local economies up and down the country. And it is the poorest and most vulnerable that are hit the hardest.’

Five million people employed in England’s public services should receive individual contracts from their employers, instead of pay and conditions set at national level. Otherwise, high profile reforms, such as the ‘pupil premium’, which would give extra money to schools with disadvantaged pupils, will achieve little. If these schools could pay significantly more to attract the best teachers, their pupils’ prospects could be transformed. National wage bargaining prevents this.

Schools in neighbourhoods like Tower Hamlets in London are doubly disadvantaged. They are competing with high-paying private sector employers on their doorstep (e.g. in the City of London), and with other schools in leafy suburbs offering the same salary and far less stress.

There are problems for the NHS as well. As Professor Wolf explains: ‘Where local private sector wages are high, recruitment is much more difficult and large numbers of expensive agency staff are needed to fill the gaps. Agency staff are expensive, bad for productivity and bad for patients - tightly regulated nurses’ pay and a strong local labour market have been linked to significantly higher fatality rates after admissions for heart attacks.’

The report finds, for poorer regions, inflexible public sector salary scales do damage in another way: they can handicap the private sector. England’s regions are as unequal today as when Labour took power, in part because employers cannot compete through lower costs. If they want good employees, they must match high, nationally set and funded public sector rates. England is, in this respect, like Germany, where the imposition of national pay-scales after unification had catastrophic consequences for the East German economy.

Individual pay scales are perfectly feasible, Professor Wolf argues. Sweden, which was once even more centralised than this country, made the shift in the 1990s. No one, including the Swedish unions, now wants a return to national scales. We in Britain should make the same change, and soon, recognising that our fiscal crisis makes flexibility more important than ever, recommends Professor Wolf .



Notes to editors

A  copy of ‘More than we bargained for: the social and economic costs of national wage bargaining’ by Professor Wolf is available at www.centreforum.org/assets/pubs/more-than-we-bargained-for.pdf

CentreForum
CentreForum is an independent liberal think tank seeking to develop evidence based, long term policy solutions to the problems facing Britain and Europe.

King's College London
King's College London is one of the top 25 universities in the world (Times Higher Education 2009) and the fourth oldest in England. A research-led university based in the heart of London, King's has more than 21,000 students from nearly 140 countries, and more than 5,700 employees. King's is in the second phase of a £1 billion redevelopment programme which is transforming its estate.

King's has an outstanding reputation for providing world-class teaching and cutting-edge research. In the 2008 Research Assessment Exercise for British universities, 23 departments were ranked in the top quartile of British universities; over half of our academic staff work in departments that are in the top 10 per cent in the UK in their field and can thus be classed as world leading. The College is in the top seven UK universities for research earnings and has an overall annual income of nearly £450 million.

King's has a particularly distinguished reputation in the humanities, law, the sciences (including a wide range of health areas such as psychiatry, medicine and dentistry) and social sciences including international affairs. It has played a major role in many of the advances that have shaped modern life, such as the discovery of the structure of DNA and research that led to the development of radio, television, mobile phones and radar. It is the largest centre for the education of healthcare professionals in Europe; no university has more Medical Research Council Centres.

King's College London and Guy's and St Thomas', King's College Hospital and South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trusts are part of King's Health Partners. King's Health Partners Academic Health Sciences Centre (AHSC) is a pioneering global collaboration between one of the world's leading research-led universities and three of London's most successful NHS Foundation Trusts, including leading teaching hospitals and comprehensive mental health services. For more information, visit: www.kingshealthpartners.org.



Further information
Alex Bevis, Public Relations Officer,
Public Relations Department
Email: alex.bevis@kcl.ac.uk Tel: 020 7848 3238

Next:
King’s business plan competition launched
Honorary Fellow wins Nobel Literature Prize
King's contributes to WHO Intervention Guidelines
Nightingale app previewed
Free radicals shown to protect the heart

Previous:
Major medical review following King’s study
King’s joins pan-European training partner
European project to reduce HIV transmission
Nanotechnology research advances
Europe Week debates


This information is provided by the Public Relations Department
Tel: 020-7848 3202  Fax: 020-7848 3739  Email: pr@kcl.ac.uk