Skip to main content

16 October 2026

King's report urges reform of DNA testing in UK immigration cases

Families seeking to prove relationships in UK immigration cases with DNA testing can face unclear testing requirements, varying tests between providers, and significant financial and practical barriers, according to new research by King’s College London.

Dna at King's event 2
The launch event of the event of the report, hosted by DNA@King's on September 28th 2026. 

The researchers found DNA evidence used to establish family relationships in UK immigration cases can be misinterpreted by decision-makers and legal practitioners and the expertise families depend on during the process is uneven, inaccessible, poorly communicated or inconsistently applied . For example, families often have little information from the Home Office and DNA testing companies about whether the DNA test they are offered is appropriate for their case.

The research, published in a new report from the One King’s Impact funded Refugee Family Reunion Project, examined how DNA evidence is produced, reported and interpreted in cases involving refugees and their families, with particular attention to children joining or remaining with non-parent relatives. As part of the Project the researchers collected data from DNA service providers, immigration lawyers and from families with lived experience.

The researchers are calling for clearer Home Office guidance and updated training for decision-makers on how DNA results should be interpreted, including how inconclusive results should be understood and how DNA evidence should be weighed alongside other evidence. They also call for greater transparency and standardisation among DNA testing providers, so that families and their advisers can better understand what tests are being offered and whether they are appropriate for their case.

Lesley Nott, Principal Investigator & Business Manager, DNA@King’s, said: “Funding from One King’s Impact enabled us to continue research on the use of DNA evidence in immigration casework and how reports are interpreted by the Home Office. Working with Linda Pedersen, we set out to map the current provision of DNA services in the UK as listed on the Ministry of Justice website. This list was set up originally to include accredited laboratories that could provide paternity tests for Court, not for complex immigration cases that require confirmation of more distant relationships. We consulted experts in immigration law and DNA service provision, and importantly, families themselves. Families deserve to know which laboratories are processing their personal data and whether the tests they pay for will provide a conclusive report to support their application in order to select the right service for their needs.”

Home Office guidance states that providing DNA evidence is voluntary and there is no mandatory requirement to do so. However, the researchers found that legal representatives and charities often take on responsibility for suggesting and arranging DNA testing. Families naturally want to submit a strong application and may feel they have no choice but to pay for a DNA test as part of their evidence.

The researchers found that DNA results are not always interpreted correctly. A DNA test cannot simply give a “yes” or “no” answer about whether two people are related. An inconclusive result may mean that the test was unable to give a clear answer, rather than that the claimed relationship is unlikely. The researchers found that this distinction is not always understood when DNA evidence is considered in immigration cases.

The research also found that not all DNA tests are designed to answer the same questions. A standard parent-child test may not be suitable when a family is trying to establish a more complex relationship, such as between siblings, grandparents or other relatives. Providers may differ in the number of STRs they analyse and how they account for other possible family relationships, but these differences are often not clear to families or their legal advisers.

The researchers also looked at the companies offering DNA tests for UK immigration cases. They found 23 companies and agencies were advertising these tests in June 2026, yet there are only 12 organisations approved by the Ministry of Justice to carry them out. Some of these organisations are not accredited laboratories, they are agencies sub-contracting the DNA service to laboratories with the appropriate UKAS accreditation. This is not always clear in commercial public facing websites. In some cases, it was not clear to customers which approved laboratory would actually analyse their DNA and which are agencies utilising accredited laboratory services sometimes outside of the UK. Families may not be aware that their samples and data are being sent to be processed in Europe or USA.

Professor Denise Syndercombe Court, Professor of Forensic Genetics at King’s College London, said:

“DNA evidence is powerful, but it is not simply a yes or no answer. The meaning of a result depends on the relationship being tested, the people included and the methods used. Our research shows a need for much greater transparency about how tests are selected and how their results should be interpreted, particularly when the consequences for families can be so significant.”

Families can also face significant financial and practical barriers to testing. Some families reported borrowing money from their communities to pay for testing, while others, including children, faced long journeys or unsafe travel routes to provide samples.

The researchers call for greater standardisation and transparency among DNA testing providers, better public information which tests should be employed to address relationships other than standard paternity, and fairer consideration of whether DNA testing costs could be covered through legal aid.

The researchers also argue that the experiences of refugee and migrating families should be recognised as an important source of expertise when evidential requirements are designed and reformed. “The process begins with humans and ends with humans”, says Linda Pedersen, Visiting Research Associate, King’s College London.

Lesley Nott, Principal Investigator & Business Manager, DNA@King’s, said: “We hope this report will have an impact on transparency of accreditation, standards and quality in DNA testing on the Ministry of Justice list. We recommend a toolkit be provided with accessible guidance and resources for families and their legal representatives and made available on the Home Office website alongside the recently updated DNA Policy Guidance. Knowledge exchange and updated training for decision makers will impact on smoother application processing and prompt decisions for families.”

The report was presented at an event hosted by DNA@King's titled 'DNA Evidence, Interpretation & Services in Immigration Casework' on September 28th. 

DNA at King's event

The event included presentations on the report’s findings and the science behind using DNA to establish family relationships, followed by an expert panel discussion exploring standards and the use and interpretation of DNA evidence in immigration casework.

A wide variety of professionals with an interest in the field attended, including CEOs and managers of accredited laboratories and agencies, immigration and surrogacy lawyers, charities supporting migrants and journalists, and families with lived experience.

Click here to download the report.

For more information about the project: Expanding Safe Pathways to Sanctuary: Refugee Family Reunion | King's College London

In this story

Lesley  Nott

Business Engagement & Communications Manager

Denise Syndercombe Court

Professor of Forensic Genetics

Linda Lund Pedersen

Visiting Research Associate