Skip to main content
HealthTechnology & Science

Remote vs in-person consultations

The Covid-19 pandemic changed how mental health care is delivered in the UK and worldwide, with a rapid shift from face-to-face mental health consultations to telephone and video calls.

However, little is known about what happened beyond the Covid-19 period, to what extent these consultation methods are used today, and how they affect care and health outcomes, especially in mental health where the relationship between the patient and heath professional is crucial.

Background

Remote consultations, using the telephone and online platforms, can help more people access mental health care, particularly in areas with limited services such as some rural areas. However, mental health professionals know that the relationship between patient and provider can affect treatment outcomes, and we do not know how remote care might change this relationship.

Some studies show that remote consultations can be as effective as in-person visits for primary care and mental health. In the UK, one study showed that by April 2020, 90 per cent of primary care consultations were done remotely. While phone consultations worked for most issues, the main challenge for doctors was to decide when to see patients in person if they noticed increased clinical risks.

How are we involving patients and service users?

Service users have been involved from the start, including in the design of the study. They will continue to be involved throughout the project, co-developing patient-facing materials, discussing the study findings, and sharing the main findings and recommendations.

The study began in October 2023 and is expected to finish in September 2026.

Funding and support

This research is supported by the London Interdisciplinary Social Science Doctoral Training Programme (LISS DTP), Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC), South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust and the National Institute for Health and Care Research Applied Research Collaboration (NIHR ARC) South London.

Aims

The aim of this research is to examine the differences between remote and in-person mental health consultations, exploring how they affect patients' health outcomes and how well they can be implemented into practice.

Methods

This study will use three main research methods:

  1. Umbrella review: assessing existing research on how remote and in-person mental health consultations differ for patients with different mental health conditions in reducing symptoms and other health outcomes.
  2. Analysis of electronic health records: we will analyse anonymised electronic health information from the three King’s Health Partners NHS trusts to compare how in-person and remote mental health consultations affect health outcomes. This includes assessing symptom reduction, quality of life and treatment plans.
  3. Interviews: with service users and mental health professionals to explore their views and experiences of remote and in-person consultations in mental health services in south London.

Keywords

REMOTE CONSULTATIONSIN-PERSONFACE-TO-FACEHEALTH SERVICES RESEARCHMENTAL HEALTH