Lessons from the past
Competition law has a history of intellectual traditions, including Ordoliberalism, the Harvard structuralist school, the Chicago School, and the neo-Brandeisian school. These traditions diverge not only in their understanding of the objectives of competition law, but also in the importance they attribute to price and output effects as indicators of competitive harm. While some schools emphasise economic efficiency and consumer welfare, others place greater weight on market structure, for example.
At the conference, Eun Hye Kim presented how the Rasch model, a statistical method used in psychometrics to measure abilities, attitudes, or other traits that cannot be observed directly, can be used to measure incremental change in the case law over time. By applying a mathematical scaling structure, she created a methodology that allows her to map the pendulum of jurisprudential paradigms. Looking at the ‘more economic approach’ as the contemporary enforcement paradigm of the European Union, she found that while the Court of Justice has tended to reinforce it, the Advocates General tend to become an increasing counterweight, pushing for a more diverse approach to competition law objectives.
Furthermore, Kaarish Shah Maniar underlined that studying early concepts is essential for drawing modern conclusions. When examining the intellectual history of monopolies shaped by Sir Edward Coke, one of the greatest jurists of the Elizabethan and Jacobean eras, he found that in the early seventeenth century, Coke viewed monopolies as political institutions, like private governments endangering constitutional liberties. While the contemporary perception is that monopolies are bad for competition, a more differentiated view inspired by early thinkers like Sir Edward Coke is needed. For example, a suggestion arising from the subsequent discussion was that policy could possibly allow bigness for the sake of its efficiencies, but subject dominant social media platforms to more democratic accountability.