Skip to main content
KBS_Icon_questionmark link-ico
Six members of a panel seated on a stage. There is a projector with a presentation behind them. ;

The Mission of Scholarship: Reflections on the Past, Present, and Future of Competition Law in Light of the 21st Annual ASCOLA Conference 2026

Jasmin Schulz

LLM Student in Competition Law, The Dickson Poon School of Law

19 August 2026

What is the impact of competition law scholarship? This question kicked off the 21st Annual ASCOLA conference 2026, co-hosted by University College London and King’s College London and supported by Queen Mary University of London and the University of Cambridge.

The ASCOLA conference took place from 1 - 3 July 2026. ASCOLA stands for Academic Society for Competition Law, and is an influential independent international association of scholars who research and teach competition law, competition policy, and the economics of competition.

At this year’s three-day conference, more than 160 participants from five continents came together to identify and discuss gaps and issues of competition law and regulation across five parallel streams, 28 panels and 102 papers, allowing for an extensive debate across a wide range of interesting topics relating to competition law foundations, digital regulation, geopolitics, and resilience. The only downside was that, given the parallel sessions, one could not attend them all. A full list of panels and papers discussed are available.

Particular thanks are due to the organising committee for creating such an engaging and thought-provoking conference. The discussions over the three days have once again demonstrated the value of bringing together scholars from different jurisdictions and disciplines to reflect on competition law and policy. The competition law community will reconvene at next year’s Annual ASCOLA conference 2027, which will be held at Korea University in Seoul.

Competition law scholarship reveals its true impact only when viewed through the lens of time. The conference invited us to reflect not only on where competition law scholarship stands today, but also on its past, and its future that will continue to shape the evolution of this area of law.

 

A wide shot showing some part of the audience and six panelists on the stage.

Lessons from the past 

Competition law has a history of intellectual traditions, including Ordoliberalism, the Harvard structuralist school, the Chicago School, and the neo-Brandeisian school. These traditions diverge not only in their understanding of the objectives of competition law, but also in the importance they attribute to price and output effects as indicators of competitive harm. While some schools emphasise economic efficiency and consumer welfare, others place greater weight on market structure, for example.

At the conference, Eun Hye Kim presented how the Rasch model, a statistical method used in psychometrics to measure abilities, attitudes, or other traits that cannot be observed directly, can be used to measure incremental change in the case law over time. By applying a mathematical scaling structure, she created a methodology that allows her to map the pendulum of jurisprudential paradigms. Looking at the ‘more economic approach’ as the contemporary enforcement paradigm of the European Union, she found that while the Court of Justice has tended to reinforce it, the Advocates General tend to become an increasing counterweight, pushing for a more diverse approach to competition law objectives.

Furthermore, Kaarish Shah Maniar underlined that studying early concepts is essential for drawing modern conclusions. When examining the intellectual history of monopolies shaped by Sir Edward Coke, one of the greatest jurists of the Elizabethan and Jacobean eras, he found that in the early seventeenth century, Coke viewed monopolies as political institutions, like private governments endangering constitutional liberties. While the contemporary perception is that monopolies are bad for competition, a more differentiated view inspired by early thinkers like Sir Edward Coke is needed. For example, a suggestion arising from the subsequent discussion was that policy could possibly allow bigness for the sake of its efficiencies, but subject dominant social media platforms to more democratic accountability. 

Five members of a panel seated on a stage. There is a projector with a presentation behind them.

The interplay of the past and the present

Not only can early views like those of Sir Edward Coke be used to rethink current approaches, but the past can also serve as an important comparator to draw analogies for understanding present challenges.

For example, Liang Li tested whether the doctrine on excessive pricing can be used as an analogy to control excessive data use by digital platforms. Equally, Andrew McLean wanted to use the knowledge from predatory pricing strategies to draft competition law responses to the phenomenon of venture capital predation. Unlike in traditional predatory pricing theory, in this new scenario of venture capital predation, the predator is not the dominant incumbent, but the challenger entering the market while backed by large investments.

Furthermore, some legal concepts are rooted in the interplay of the past and the present. For example, remedy design in ex post competition law cases is guided by the aim of restoration. Francesco Ducci, emphasised the underuse of disgorgement of gains illicitly obtained through competition law violations, presenting a paper written together with Maytal Gilboa. He then explained the opportunities and justifications of this remedial approach that is a common principle in many jurisdictions for awarding damages. Remedy design can be considered one of the most important current issues of competition law, in particular in the digital sector. However, Macarena Alliende argued that not only do remedies in competition law cases often fail to restore harmful effects to the market due to poor design, but they also fail due to judicial and institutional constraints. This highlights that procedure is important for effective competition law enforcement and that procedural issues deserve more scholarly attention.

The design of institutions shapes not only how competition law responds to harm, but also which forms of harm it recognises in the first place. Ever since the beginning of the digital age, the scope of competition law concerns has significantly broadened, which enriched the content of the panels at this year’s conference, where scholars exchanged views on issues of data power, democracy, platform regulation, algorithms, labour law implications, and corporate structures. Yet, enforcement priority setting is still guided by consumer welfare considerations. Against this background, Or Brook presented a paper co-authored with Kati Cseres on how the authorities should implement a cycle of responsive priority setting of competition law enforcement to include wider social, economic and democratic concerns.

In light of today’s digital realities, Tristan Rohner and Juliane Mendelsohn raised the important question of how competition law and regulation could be used to protect political discourse on social media platforms, where content moderation is guided by a commercial rationale to keep users engaged rather than presenting diverse, educative, and truthful sources. Historical foundations such as those of Sir Edward Coke, applied to the realities of the digital age, will help to shape today's debate on how to regulate digital platforms and mobile ecosystems.

Moreover, the transition from ex post enforcement to ex ante regulation by means of the Digital Markets Act (DMA) represents a decisive strategic shift from backwards looking rules to a law more forwards looking and rooted in the present in European Union competition law. However, this comes with new challenges. Jens-Uwe Franck, presenting the findings of him and Mauro Hartl, warned that prescriptive regulatory tools can result in undesirable effects, while Daniel Mândrescu stressed the need to study overlaps and maximise synergies between Article 102 TFEU and the DMA. As regulatory frameworks become more complex, it will be interesting to see the jurisprudential evolution towards either fragmentation or alignment.

A wide shot showing some part of the audience and six panelists on the stage.

Looking ahead to the future: New challenges, new opportunities

If there was one message that resonated throughout the conference, it was that many questions remain unanswered (or the answers change over time), leaving a great deal of work for competition law scholarship. There are new regulatory overlaps within the field, and there is also the emergence of overlaps of legal disciplines, where competition law increasingly intertwines with data regulation, data protection, corporate law, labour law, and even questions of democracy. Rather than treating these emerging challenges as isolated issues, the conference showed the importance of maximising the interplay between different legal frameworks.

We live in a complex world, where data has become a new currency, AI is reshaping markets at speed, and digital ecosystems require regulators to think beyond traditional market boundaries. Furthermore, new global market players besides US firms are emerging in a way that not only Amazon and Google, but also Temu may soon be part of an antitrust paradox.

References to science fiction served as a timely reminder that technological progress without effective governance can have unintended consequences. Anush Ganesh illustrated this by explaining the concentrated trade structures and lack of competition concerning the spice trade in Frank Herbert’s Dune. Lyuxing Tao spoke about cognitive infrastructure power and coerced neuro-consent. As illustrated in the ‘Common People’ episode of the Black Mirror series, when companies acquire the power to control human cognition through medical care subscription models, consent to medical treatment can no longer be considered freely given, as people’s lives depend on it.

Overall, the conference brought out the vast potential of competition law to address these challenges when properly adapted against new threats to competition.

Conference participants seated with someone infront speaking to them.

Conclusion

Looking at competition law through the lens of time reveals progress significantly shaped by scholarly debate. Returning to the opening question, there was broad agreement that the significance and impact of competition law research should not be measured solely by the number of citations or the number of new laws enacted, but by how it improves people’s lives. Ultimately, making a difference for the people in our economy is the impact that competition law scholars strive towards when constantly challenging the current legal framework, the regulators, the market players, and not least, when challenging themselves through the exchange of ideas and critical debate at the Annual ASCOLA conference.

Related links

Latest news