Katherine Happold in the cabinet of Advocate General Biondi
Holden Caulfield, the well-loved antihero of The Catcher in the Rye, was annoyed by many things, like when “somebody says the coffee’s all ready and it isn’t”. I am sure he would feel better knowing the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) takes his concerns seriously. I can attest to this, as in September I was fortunate enough to observe an array of first-rate lawyers and judges exchange grievances about the circulation of a few coffee machines. I followed this case during my week-long placement in the cabinet of Advocate General Biondi, by virtue of the generous Chloros Scholarship.
In preparation for the hearing, I had considered and researched the applicable secondary legislation, which I was able to discuss with the Advocate General and his référendaire. I reviewed a draft translation of an Opinion originally written in French. The exercise offered me some insight into the significance of language across the EU in ensuring mutual understanding. This linguistic diplomacy is also present at hearings. I was able to spend a morning observing the Grand Chamber, where I was surprised by the scale of the Court’s live interpretation. For another référendaire I summarised ECtHR case law and compiled some recent State aid decisions to assist the Advocate General with a speech he delivered.
King's College London has a longstanding relationship with different partner universities across the European Union(EU). As a personal beneficiary of these ties, I completed my double degree in English law and French law between London and Paris. My time across two jurisdictions widened my interest in the differences in legal analysis. In civil jurisdictions, we are taught to reason from the law down to the facts. The common law, however, reasons upwards towards the answer. I was encouraged to apply for the Chloros Scholarship as the CJEU is an apex court for both civil and common law jurisdictions. This offered me the unique opportunity to speak to members of the Court from civil law backgrounds. I spent a day between the cabinets of Judge Gratsias and Advocate General Rantos, who, along with their référendaires, were very generous with their time and advice.