You press the start button. You boot up the game. In doing so, you also launch a metamorphosis of space and the self. The interplay between your brain and your controller creates a liminal space, what Jesper Juul calls the “half real”. While Juul’s theory may be unfamiliar by name to many gamers, it feels instantly recognisable in practice. The lumbering zombies you face, the cosy village you build, or the team of monsters you raise may be fictional, but the hours you spend struggling against or collaborating with that fiction are real.
Grounded cognition specialists support the concept of the half real by explaining our brain’s tendency to see the controller as part of ourselves, thereby overlaying the video game experience onto our terrestrial one, allowing us to immerse ourselves in digital worlds by merging with what we see on screen. This is most apparent in our relationship with the avatar which to an extent becomes us. Anyone who has played Mario Kart will recognise the frustration of a blue shell knocking them from first place to eighth. In that moment, no one says “Mario” hit “Luigi”. They say “you” hit “me”. In those moments, there is no clear distinction between player and avatar. Instead, there is a hybrid entity that is both/neither.
In this act of transformation lies the inherent queerness of this medium, the ability to reshape ourselves into uncanny hybrids of digital code and human flesh. At its core, queerness is grounded in potential and difference, setting itself apart from monolithic constructions of identity by refusing to occupy a fixed positionality. Saying you’re queer simply means you are not simultaneously cis-gendered and heterosexual. What’s left unspoken is the unlimited potential of what you may be, what you may become and the rich ways identities may intersect, overlap or crash to make the glorious you.
A main reason for the tension between the expansive queer potential and comparatively limited physical manifestations of queerness is the constraints of our corporal realities. Within the liminal space between video games and ourselves, we move closer to the limitless. Once we allow our brains to no longer distinguish flesh from pixel, the chimeric form we take allows us to play with the impossible. While playing with our bodies or genders is often highly politized and carries risk, the ease and temporal nature of playing as an avatar is safer. In this space we can develop an antagonist tension between the self, the other, our desired and what we don't want in which a stronger sense of identity may flourish.
Moments of dissonance from, or alterations to, the self are often the most revealing. By merging with another, we can interrogate which parts of ourselves we value, which we miss, and what new additions we might want to incorporate. When I see Lara Croft’s hyper feminine pixels as an extension of my organic self, my relationship to the feminine begins to shift. The resulting tension, affinity or indifference can echo within me once I shed her. These transformations offer a reprieve from the pressure to assimilate to societal constructs. In these moments, aspects of the self that are usually buried are allowed to flourish. When we return to our physical bodies, we do so with both greater clarity about what we do/do not want and a forward-looking intentionality to embody those characteristics.
My MA Global Cultures thesis explored this, and showed how video games are not just sites of play, but spaces where identity itself can be reimagined, rehearsed and ultimately recreated. Of the nine queer men whom I interviewed, eight described video games as a tool for exploring their identity, and seven said they played a significant role in their decision to come out publicly. A recurring theme was the role of cross gender avatar play in helping them reconcile the tension between how they felt and how they believed they were expected to feel, particularly in relation to masculinity. The participants recalled growing up with societal narratives compounding strength and a prescribed performance of masculinity which they often saw as harmful – including to themselves. Many participants described feeling that a form of masculinity they did not identify with was an essential prerequisite for achieving qualities they valued, such as strength, intelligence, and capability. Lara Croft was frequently cited as pivotal in helping them challenging the false narratives of the linear nature of masculinity. Embodying these characteristics with a body they had been told could not hold them was the start of them unlearning rigid ideas of gender, strength, masculinity and their interplay.
Over time all participants developed a frustration with the performative self of their “real world” and began to take steps to change themselves and the spaces they inhabited to align closer with the world they experienced in the half-real. All participants took steps to distance themselves from gender normativity, varying from subtle changes to their gender performativity to transitioning genders.
If pressing start begins a metamorphosis, then switching off becomes its crescendo. We respawn from our hybrid body into our worldly one, carrying the vivid imprint of what was and a blueprint for what can be, with the bravery to pursue the new possibilities now beginning to render around us.